ricoeurian hermeneutical approach; case study: illustrations of sam mirza's hafez's divan*

نویسندگان

ادهم ضرغام

استادیار دانشکدۀ هنرهای تجسّمی، پردیس هنرهای زیبا، دانشگاه تهران، تهران، ایران. مریم عادل

چکیده

after a long march of history of developments, hermeneutics, the theory of text interpretation, totally focused on understanding, has nowadays been wider scope that eventually includes artworks. hermeneutics refers to different approaches due to its theoretical versatility and associated applied paradigms including ricoeur’s textual hermeneutics. the latter may be best described as text-oriented interpretation which could not be dominantly focused on text as the reader has been considered being the constitutive partner in understanding the text particularly since early 20th century. text-oriented hermeneutics roots in hermeneutical affirmation of interpretive autonomy of biblical scripture in medieval centuries and during 16th century protestant reformation; also, introduction of  autonomous being of language in modern 20th century hermeneutics. paul ricoeur, contemporary figurehead hermeneut, assumed self-hermeneutics the primary intent of the practical approach he later defined as interpretative dialectic between guessing and validating. present research aims to do a ricoeur’s hermeneutics-analysis of illustrations of sam mirza’s hafez's divan. first chapter is dedicated to review of ricoeur’s textual hermeneutics, the dialectic between hermeneutics and art and finally, ricoeur’s practical philosophy regarding illustrations and paintings as a broader sense of text. studies on fine art-hermeneutics links and certain interpretations based on ricoeurian methodology are discussed in second chapter. ricoeurian approach to these illustrations is not deemed impracticable; yet, textual interpretations and understandings are assumed personal according to ricoeur’s theory of text to which discernment of accurate vs. misinterpretation is of no concern; the probable hermeneutical explanations can thus only be methodologically assessed. ricoeur's theory of interpretation, thus, has constantly faced two major challenges: first, traditional values of textual congruence and -plenitude have never been utterly fulfilled within his sphere of interpretation of symbols given he considers no utmost and inevitably unerring textual meaning. second, ricoeurian hermeneutics perfectly focuses on textuality as well as illustrative semiotics-which is the case. promotion of the textual analysis beyond their structural significance and seeming narration of the illustrations will not make included linguistic semantic elements steadily revealing about the illustrations. interpretations even get muddled up when it comes to near eastern poetic texts such as hafiz’s works due to its plural aspects of meaning as well as unique expressive form of ode which fuel the interpretive ambiguity of associated illustrations and challenge the rationality of potential semiotic deductions. semantic ambiguity due to lack of enough illustration-associated textual evidence, and also, obvious form and content association between illustrations and the words cause illustrations to be further seen as textual components rather than independent subject matters. closer look at illustrations of sam mirza's custom version of hafiz's divan suggests that these paintings and the textual originality may not be truly divided. text-dependent analyses of the paintings could definitely clarify the interpretations and this is precisely where they deviate from ricoeur’stheory because the text is already seen as the genuine interpretive backbone and major analytical tool of the paintings. finally, author-oriented- and other context-based approaches is suggested in case the interpreter is about to achieve coherent explanations of either word-independent illustrations

برای دانلود باید عضویت طلایی داشته باشید

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

منابع مشابه

from linguistics to literature: a linguistic approach to the study of linguistic deviations in the turkish divan of shahriar

chapter i provides an overview of structural linguistics and touches upon the saussurean dichotomies with the final goal of exploring their relevance to the stylistic studies of literature. to provide evidence for the singificance of the study, chapter ii deals with the controversial issue of linguistics and literature, and presents opposing views which, at the same time, have been central to t...

15 صفحه اول

esp needs analysis of iranian ma students: a case study of university of isfahan

نیاز سنجی دانشجویان کارشناسی ارشد ایرانی در رابطه با زبان تخصصی: مطالعه ای در دانشگاه اصفهان هدف از این مطالعه بررسی نیازهای یادگیری زبان خارجی دانشجویان کارشناسی ارشد دانشجویان دانشگاه اصفهان در رشته های زیست شناسی، روانشناسی، تربیت بدنی، حسابداری و فلسفه ی غرب میباشد. در مجموع 80 دانشجودر پنج رشته ی متفاوت از دانشگاه اصفهان در این پژوهش شرکت داشتند.علاوه بر این هشتاد دانشجو،25 استاد دروس ت...

15 صفحه اول

the effect of consciousness raising (c-r) on the reduction of translational errors: a case study

در دوره های آموزش ترجمه استادان بیشتر سعی دارند دانشجویان را با انواع متون آشنا سازند، درحالی که کمتر به خطاهای مکرر آنان در متن ترجمه شده می پردازند. اهمیت تحقیق حاضر مبنی بر ارتکاب مکرر خطاهای ترجمانی حتی بعد از گذراندن دوره های تخصصی ترجمه از سوی دانشجویان است. هدف از آن تاکید بر خطاهای رایج میان دانشجویان مترجمی و کاهش این خطاها با افزایش آگاهی و هوشیاری دانشجویان از بروز آنها است.از آنجا ک...

15 صفحه اول

a case study of the two translators of the holy quran: tahereh saffarzadeh and laleh bakhtiar

بطورکلی، کتاب های مقدسی همچون قران کریم را خوانندگان میتوان مطابق با پیش زمینه های مختلفی که درند درک کنند. محقق تلاش کرده نقش پیش زمینه اجتماعی-فرهنگی را روی ایدئولوژی های مترجمین زن و در نتیجه تاثیراتش را روی خواندن و ترجمه آیات قرآن کریم بررسی کند و ببیند که آیا تفاوت های واژگانی عمده ای میان این مترجمین وجود دارد یا نه. به این منظور، ترجمه 24 آیه از آیات قرآن کریم مورد بررسی مقایسه ای قرار ...

15 صفحه اول

formation and evolution of regional organizations: the case study of the economic cooperation organization (eco)

abstract because of the many geopolitical, geo economical and geo strategically potentials and communicational capabilities of eco region, members can expand the convergence and the integration in base of this organization that have important impact on members development and expanding peace in international and regional level. based on quality analyzing of library findings and experts interv...

15 صفحه اول

منابع من

با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید


عنوان ژورنال:
هنرهای تجسمی

جلد ۲۰، شماره ۲، صفحات ۲۳-۳۸

کلمات کلیدی
after a long march of history of developments hermeneutics the theory of text interpretation totally focused on understanding has nowadays been wider scope that eventually includes artworks. hermeneutics refers to different approaches due to its theoretical versatility and associated applied paradigms including ricoeur’s textual hermeneutics. the latter may be best described as text oriented interpretation which could not be dominantly focused on text as the reader has been considered being the constitutive partner in understanding the text particularly since early 20th century. text oriented hermeneutics roots in hermeneutical affirmation of interpretive autonomy of biblical scripture in medieval centuries and during 16th century protestant reformation; also introduction of  autonomous being of language in modern 20th century hermeneutics. paul ricoeur contemporary figurehead hermeneut assumed self hermeneutics the primary intent of the practical approach he later defined as interpretative dialectic between guessing and validating. present research aims to do a ricoeur’s hermeneutics analysis of illustrations of sam mirza’s hafez's divan. first chapter is dedicated to review of ricoeur’s textual hermeneutics the dialectic between hermeneutics and art and finally ricoeur’s practical philosophy regarding illustrations and paintings as a broader sense of text. studies on fine art hermeneutics links and certain interpretations based on ricoeurian methodology are discussed in second chapter. ricoeurian approach to these illustrations is not deemed impracticable; yet textual interpretations and understandings are assumed personal according to ricoeur’s theory of text to which discernment of accurate vs. misinterpretation is of no concern; the probable hermeneutical explanations can thus only be methodologically assessed. ricoeur's theory of interpretation thus has constantly faced two major challenges: first traditional values of textual congruence and plenitude have never been utterly fulfilled within his sphere of interpretation of symbols given he considers no utmost and inevitably unerring textual meaning. second ricoeurian hermeneutics perfectly focuses on textuality as well as illustrative semiotics which is the case. promotion of the textual analysis beyond their structural significance and seeming narration of the illustrations will not make included linguistic semantic elements steadily revealing about the illustrations. interpretations even get muddled up when it comes to near eastern poetic texts such as hafiz’s works due to its plural aspects of meaning as well as unique expressive form of ode which fuel the interpretive ambiguity of associated illustrations and challenge the rationality of potential semiotic deductions. semantic ambiguity due to lack of enough illustration associated textual evidence and also obvious form and content association between illustrations and the words cause illustrations to be further seen as textual components rather than independent subject matters. closer look at illustrations of sam mirza's custom version of hafiz's divan suggests that these paintings and the textual originality may not be truly divided. text dependent analyses of the paintings could definitely clarify the interpretations and this is precisely where they deviate from ricoeur’stheory because the text is already seen as the genuine interpretive backbone and major analytical tool of the paintings. finally author oriented and other context based approaches is suggested in case the interpreter is about to achieve coherent explanations of either word independent illustrations

میزبانی شده توسط پلتفرم ابری doprax.com

copyright © 2015-2023