Comparison of Self, Peer, and Clinical Teacher Evaluation in Clinical Skills Evaluation Process of Midwifery Students
Introduction: In order to have a precise judgment on performance, a variety of data resources are needed. In this regard, experts emphasize on employing different assessment groups for determining achievement of learning objectives by students. This study was performed to compare self, peer, and teacher evaluation in the process of midwifery students' clinical skills evaluation at delivery room of Fatemieh and Imam Hossein Hospitals affiliated to Shahrood University of Medical Sciences. Methods: In this descriptive cross sectional study, 85 senior midwifery students were selected and evaluated by 3 methods of self, peer, and clinical teacher evaluation. Their clinical competencies were assessed using a researcher made questionnaire including two parts of general and specific skills evaluation. Data were analyzed by SPSS software using one-way analysis of variance and Tukey. Results: The mean and standard deviation of the self-evaluation, peer evaluation, and clinical teacher’s evaluation of general clinical skills were 4.21±0.46, 4.21±0.28, and 3.97±0.47, respectively. Considering specific clinical skills, the mean and standard deviation of self-evaluation, peer evaluation, and evaluation by clinical teachers were 3.91±0.54, 3.87±0.27, and 3.66±0.41, respectively. Analysis of variance revealed a significant difference among three methods of evaluation considering general and specific clinical skills. Conclusion: With regard to scores dissimilarity in different assessment techniques, self-evaluation and peer evaluation could be considered as supplementary methods for other evaluation methods in the evaluation of students' clinical performance.
Evaluation of students' clinical skills: Agreement of self-assessment and clinical teacher assessment scores
Abstract Introduction: The most essential part of any training program is evaluation, because by doing so, the shortcomings of the program can be realized and dealt with. Clinical evaluation of students is one of the fundamental challenges in clinical nursing education. Nowadays, self-evaluation is proposed as a useful method along with student evaluation by teacher. Objective: This stu...متن کامل
a comparative study of the relationship between self-, peer-, and teacher-assessments in productive skills
تمایل به ارزیابی جایگزین و تعویض آن با آزمون سنتی مداد و کاغذ در سالهای اخیر افزایش یافته است. اکثر زبان آموزان در کلاس های زبان از نمره نهایی که استاد تعیین میکند ناراضی اند. این تحقیق جهت بررسی ارزیابی در کلاس های زبان انگلیسی به هدف رضایتمندی زبان آموزان از نمره هایشان انجام گرفته است که در آن نمرات ارائه شده توسط سه گروه ارزیاب (ارزیابی خود دانشجو، همسالان واستاد) در مهارت های تولید (تکل...15 صفحه اول
Comparing the self assessment of last year midwifery students in clinical skills with teacher assessment
Introduction: Although evaluation of students is always stressed by educational specialists, but one of the accepted methods for evaluation, is self assessment. The purpose of this study was to compare the self and instructors assessment in clinical skills of midwifery students who are completing their education in Shahrekord university of medical sciences. Methods: In a cross-sectional study, ...متن کامل
while performance-based language assessment has led to an increased authenticity and content validity in the practice of writing assessment, the reliability of ratings has become a major issue. research findings have shown different reactions by native english speaker (nes) and non-native english speaker (nns) teachers to students’ writings. the focus of this study is on investigating whether i...
The impact of using Direct observation of procedural skills (DOPS ) evaluation method on the some clinical skills of midwifery students
Background: The present study was done in order to evaluate the students’ clinical skill, enhance the quality of cares given, and consider limitations of common evaluation ways, as well as loss of texts about impact of new evaluation in education. The aim of this study was the impact of using direct observation of procedural skill (DOPS) evaluation method on some clinical skill...متن کامل
چکیده: یکی از دوره های مهم تاریخی ایران به لحاظ تأمین استقلال ملی مذهبی و حتی تأثیر آن بر فرهنگ و مذهب ایرانیان، دوره صفویه است. رسمیت دادن و رواج مذهب شیعه توسط شاه اسماعیل اول، یکی از مهمترین اقدامات این دولت محسوب می شود. بنابراین برای اجرای این سیاست، وی منصب صدارت را به عنوان منصبی مذهبی- حکو متی ایجاد کرد .این منصب از دوره ی تیموریان ایجاد شده بود ولی در اواخر این دوره اهمیت بیشتری یافت...15 صفحه اول
ذخیره در منابع من
دوره 10 شماره 4
صفحات 333- 339
تاریخ انتشار 2011-01
با دنبال کردن یک ژورنال هنگامی که شماره جدید این ژورنال منتشر می شود به شما از طریق ایمیل اطلاع داده می شود.