Let $E$ be an elliptic curve, with identity $O$, and let $C$ a cyclic subgroup of odd order $N$, over algebraically closed field $k$ $\operatorname{char} k \nmid N$. For $P \in C$, $s_P$ rational function divisor $N \cdot P - N O$. We ask whether the $N$ functions are linearly independent. generic $(E,C)$, we prove that answer is yes. bound number exceptional $(E,C)$ when prime by using geometr...