In his comment [1] on our paper [2], Pikovsky contrasts two definitions for the phase of a stochastic oscillator by way of an analytically solvable model system. In [3] the phase is defined in terms of a system of isochrons Σθ, analogous to Poincaré sections, with the property that for any initial condition on one isochron Σa, the mean first passage time (MFPT) to a second isochron Σb, b > a, w...