In NLLT 7,1 (1989), Geoffrey Pullum laments the impending doom of formal linguistics in favor of the "gentle, vague, cuddly sort of linguistics" that he feels I have been advocating since a shift of opinion that he traces to 1979. His account, however, is based on misreading and serious misunderstandings. I will keep to the latter. Two interrelated issues lie in the background: the status of fo...