A Principle-Based Analysis of Bipolar Argumentation Semantics
نویسندگان
چکیده
In this paper, we introduce and study seven types of semantics for bipolar argumentation frameworks, each extending Dung’s interpretation attack with a distinct support. First, three defence-based by adapting the notions defence. Second, examine two selection-based that select extensions counting number supports. Third, analyse traditional reduction-based under deductive necessary interpretations We provide full analysis twenty-eight ten principles.
منابع مشابه
On principle-based evaluation of extension-based argumentation semantics
The increasing variety of semantics proposed in the context of Dung’s theory of argumentation makes more and more inadequate the example-based approach commonly adopted for evaluating and comparing different semantics. To fill this gap, this paper provides two main contributions. First, a set of general criteria for semantics evaluation is introduced by proposing a formal counterpart to several...
متن کاملA bipolar argumentation-based decision framework
The paper emphasizes the bipolar nature of the evaluation of decision results by making an explicit distinction between prioritized goals to be pursued, and prioritized rejections that are stumbling blocks to be avoided. This is the basis for an argumentative framework for decision. Each decision is supported by arguments emphasizing its positive consequences in terms of goals satisfied, or rej...
متن کاملSemantics for Evidence-Based Argumentation
The identification of consistent sets of arguments is one of the most important concerns in the development of computational models of argument. Such extensions drive the defeasible reasoning process. In this paper we present a novel framework that offers a semantics for argumentation-based reasoning grounded in an intuitive notion of evidence. In building this model of evidence-based argumenta...
متن کاملa gender-based pragmatic analysis of the use of english compliment responses by iraqi efl students:a speech act perspective
تعارفات کنش های گفتاری هستند که افراد در زندگی روزمر? خود به منظور برقراری دوستی یا تداوم روابط مسالمت آمیز به کار می برند. ساز و کار تعارف مختص زبان انگلیسی یا هر زبان دیگری نیست و پدیده ای است جهانی و در همه زبانها حضور دارد. تفاوتی که از این نظر در زبانها و فرهنگ ها وجود دارد مربوط به پاسخ به این کنش گفتاری در گفتمان است. این مطالعه به بررسی تنوع پاسخ های انگلیسی و عربی به کنش گفتاری تعارف د...
Intertranslatability of Labeling-Based Argumentation Semantics
Abstract Argumentation is a simple yet powerful formalism for modeling the human reasoning and argumentation process. Various semantics have been suggested with a view of arriving at coherent outcomes of the argumentation process. Two categories of semantics are well-known, extension-based semantics and labeling-based semantics. Translations between semantics are an important area of interest t...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: Lecture Notes in Computer Science
سال: 2023
ISSN: ['1611-3349', '0302-9743']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-43619-2_15