The politics of enabling tipping points for sustainable development

Achieving most sustainable development goals (SDGs) and the Paris climate targets depends on fast transformation of complex socio-technical systems. Recent research has highlighted importance crossing positive tipping points to accelerate energy, food, transport Yet, there is a lack politics enabling such points. Here, we argue that policy strategies creation are needed. Such should harness political feedbacks from both technological behavioral changes over time. To inform strategies, need better empirical understanding how these unfold, eventually resulting in We propose novel framework structure feedback by linking it three core sustainability principles, namely efficiency, sufficiency, substitution. Our advances ongoing debates about for development. IntroductionThe achievement address urgency manifold crises, recent points.1Otto I.M. Donges J.F. Cremades R. Bhowmik A. Hewitt R.J. Lucht W. Rockström J. Allerberger F. McCaffrey M. Doe S.S.P. et al.Social dynamics stabilizing Earth’s 2050.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 2020; 117: 2354-2365Crossref PubMed Scopus (195) Google Scholar,2Smith S.R. Christie I. Willis Social intervention rapid decarbonization consider change happens.Proc. 10629-10630Crossref Scholar,3Sharpe S. Lenton T.M. Upward-scaling cascades meet goals: plausible grounds hope.Clim. Policy. 2021; 21: 421-433Crossref (23) Scholar,4Farmer J.D. Hepburn C. Ives M.C. Hale T. Wetzer Mealy P. Rafaty Srivastav Way Sensitive post-carbon transition.Science. 2019; 364: 132-134Crossref (69) Scholar,5David Tàbara Frantzeskaki N. Hölscher K. Pedde Kok Lamperti Christensen J.H. Jäger Berry Positive rapidly warming world.Curr. Opin. Environ. Sustain. 2018; 31: 120-129Crossref (56) Scholar,6Tàbara Mangalagiu D. Frantal B. Mey Maier Lilliestam Sarrica Mandel Lieu Cottone al.Towards Transformative Emergence. Research Challenges Enabling Social-Ecological Tipping Points toward Regional Sustainability Transformations. Tipping+, 2021Google ScholarInspired earth-system climate-science debate natural systems,7Lenton Early warning points.Nat. Clim. Chang. 2011; 1: 201-209Crossref (440) Scholar,8Lenton Gaffney O. Rahmstorf Richardson Steffen Schellnhuber H.J. Climate — too risky bet against.Nature. 575: 592-595Crossref (633) Scholar,9Cai Y. Lontzek T.S. Risk multiple interacting encourage CO2emission reduction.Nat. 2016; 6: 520-525Crossref (112) Scholar,10Lenton Held H. Kriegler E. Hall J.W. elements system.Proc. 2008; 105: 1786-1793Crossref (1976) Scholar,11Steffen Folke Liverman Summerhayes C.P. Barnosky A.D. Cornell S.E. Crucifix al.Trajectories earth system anthropocene.Proc. 115: 8252-8259Crossref (1141) Scholar emerging literature1Otto Scholar,12Stadelmann-Steffen Eder Harring Spilker G. Katsanidou A social mitigation: what can learn chlorofluorocarbons phase-out.Energy Res. Soc. 82102307Google Scholar,13Tàbara Zaman Ismail Takama On discovery enactment socio-ecological points: insights energy systems interventions Bangladesh Indonesia.Sustain. 2022; 17: 565-571Crossref (7) Scholar,14Mey Report with Literature Review Advancing State Art Public Policy Governance Research. 2020Google Scholar,15Andreoni Nikiforakis Siegenthaler Predicting norm controlled experiments.Proc. 118e2014893118Crossref (19) Scholar,16Nyborg Anderies J.M. Dannenberg Lindahl Schill Schlüter Adger W.N. Arrow K.J. Barrett Carpenter norms as solutions.Science. 354: 42-43Crossref (325) Scholar,17Fesenfeld L. The Political Feasibility Policy–Public Opinion Transforming Food Transport Systems. ETH, 2020https://doi.org/10.3929/ethz-b-000425564Crossref Scholar,18Lenton Benson Smith Ewer Lanel V. Petykowski Powell T.W.R. Abrams Blomsma Sharpe Operationalising towards global sustainability.Global 5Google Scholar,19Lenton change.Philos. Trans. Lond. B Biol. 37520190123Crossref (36) proposes small system, or systems, shift sensitive into qualitatively new state due strongly self-amplifying (net) mechanisms (see Figure 1 definitions). For example, “the behavior interaction feedbacks: reinforcing (positive) tend change; balancing (negative) oppose change. […] At point, dominate dynamics, propelling change” (p. 1).3 Socio-technical nested interlinked, one (e.g., rise renewable energies system), increase probability other electric cars agro-photovoltaics food system).18Lenton Accordingly, highlight that, interconnected point (sub-) could trigger related thus lead so-called large-scale transformation.3Sharpe industrial revolution England was triggered invention steam engines, which led an coal mining construction national railway network.20Smith Stirling Berkhout governance transitions.Res. 2005; 34: 1491-1510Crossref (1297) As this example shows, niche innovations technologies behaviors gain momentum non-linear previously dominant systems.21Geels F.W. Sovacool B.K. Schwanen Sorrell Sociotechnical transitions deep decarbonization.Science. 2017; 357: 1242-1244Crossref (397) Scholar,22Geels Grand societal challenges industry-environment inter-actions: developing multi-dimensional triple embeddedness framework.Res. 2013; 43: 261-277Crossref (158) Scholar,23Turnheim Geels destabilisation existing regimes : confronting case study British industry (1913–1967).Res. 42: 1749-1767Crossref (193) ScholarWhile transition research21Geels Scholar,27Rosenbloom Markard Fuenfschilling Why carbon pricing not sufficient mitigate change—and “sustainability policy” help.Proc. 8664-8668Crossref (83) Scholar,28Meckling Kelsey Biber Zysman Winning coalitions policy.Science. 2015; 349: 1170-1171Crossref (151) literature tipping1Otto have potential change, only recently scholars started build comprehensive frameworks empirically assessing conditions triggers mitigation.12Stadelmann-Steffen Scholar,29Winkelmann E.K. Milkoreit Heitzig Wiedermann Wunderling Timothy processes action: conceptual framework.Ecol. Econ. 192107242Google al.,18Lenton building thinking Meadows’ “leverage points”’ framework,24Abson D.J. Fischer Leventon Newig Schomerus Vilsmaier U. Von Wehrden Abernethy C.D. Jager N.W. Lang Leverage transformation.Ambio. 46: 30-39Crossref (520) Scholar,25Meadows D.H. Points: Places Intervene System. Academy Systems Change, 1999Google Scholar,26Meadows Thinking Systems: Primer. Chelsea Green Publishing, 2008Google rarely close but require intentional forcing. In sense, al.18Lenton Scholar,30Food Land Use CoalitionAccelerating 10 Critical Transitions: Transformation. Coalition, studying price reductions clean technologies, shifts norms) triggering through rather perturbations. instance, Lenton3Sharpe show UK between late 2015 2018 exceed coal-to-gas switching made gas relatively cheaper than coal. This reversed merit order different contribute electricity production exponentially decreased coal-generated United Kingdom.3Sharpe Furthermore, several scholars18Lenton Scholar,31Ingold Christopoulos Resilience stability networks.in: ECPR conference. contagion social-institutional network structures acceleration diffusion part EU + project, Lilliestam14Mey reviewed public its roots science work on, e.g., critical junctures, path dependencies, punctuated equilibria, external shocks. review al.13Tàbara mention important role timing specific sequence events strategic agents across political, social, economic contexts points.14Mey effective mitigation been shown be more actor-driven previous approaches suggested.2Smith al.5David stress strategically agents’ capacities “to implement pathways solutions achieve transformative vision world.” Existing also puts forward necessary synergies learning systems5David might interrelated behavioral, spheres.12Stadelmann-Steffen ScholarBuilding work, interdisciplinary explicitly define elite mass associated design policies, distribute material immaterial resources, capacities, actors time32Schmid Beaton Kern Mcculloch Sugathan Urpelainen Elite vs . transitions.Environ. Innov. Transit. 41: 67-70Crossref (3) Scholar,33Jacobs A.M. making long term advanced democracies.Annu. Rev. Polit. 19: 433-454Crossref (53) Scholar,34Jacobs Governing Long Term: Democracy Politics Investment. Cambridge University Press, 2011Crossref (164) Scholar,35Finnegan J.J. Institutions, foundations long-term policymaking.Comp. Stud. 55: 1198-1235Crossref (6) 2). Specifically, benefit incorporating literature36Béland Schlager Varieties research: looking backward, moving forward.Policy 47: 184-205Crossref (60) Scholar,37Pierson When effect becomes cause: change.World 1993; 45: 595-628Crossref (1343) Scholar,38Pierson Increasing returns, dependence, politics.Am. 2000; 94: 251-267Crossref (3919) Scholar,39Schmidt Sewerin Technology driver politics.Nat. Energy. 2: 17084-17184Crossref Scholar,40Schmid Schmidt Explaining advocacy coalition feedback.Policy 48: 1109-1134Crossref Scholar,41Fesenfeld Rudolph Bernauer framing, support costly waste regulation.Nat. Food. 3: 227-235Crossref (2) Scholar,42Jordan Matt Designing policies intentionally stick: changing climate.Policy 2014; 227-247Crossref (130) Scholar,43Rosenbloom Meadowcroft Cashore Stability policy? Harnessing feedback, pathways.Energy 50: 168-178Crossref (55) gap.Figure 2Harnessing policy-induced enable pointsShow full captionTo reduce barriers points, blue-shaded area policymakers develop changes. Definitions: process policies.32Schmid conceptualize power relations policymaking set organized interest groups influential individuals. Mass unfolds participation citizens process, movements opinion, voting behavior, norms. frequently interact each parties often channel interactions process. Technological (i.e., outcomes relevant SDGs) results output). While understand manufacturing their products along supply chains sector assembly lines solar photovoltaic cells), includes actions users at various chain farmers end-consumers).View Large Image ViewerDownload Hi-res image Download (PPT)Policymakers use removal fossil-fuel subsidies2Smith Scholar) self-reinforcing state.1Otto current enough. Many primarily focus exploiting marginal efficiency innovation gains, co-creating pathway transforming systems.1Otto Scholar,44Creutzig Roy Lamb W.F. Azevedo I.M.L. Bruine de Bruin Dalkmann Edelenbosc