Shared care obesity management in 3-10 year old children: 12 month outcomes of HopSCOTCH randomised trial

OBJECTIVE To determine whether general practice surveillance for childhood obesity, followed by obesity management across primary and tertiary care settings using a shared care model, improves body mass index and related outcomes in obese children aged 3-10 years. DESIGN Randomised controlled trial. SETTING 22 family practices (35 participating general practitioners) and a tertiary weight management service (three paediatricians, two dietitians) in Melbourne, Australia. PARTICIPANTS Children aged 3-10 years with body mass index above the 95th centile recruited through their general practice between July 2009 and April 2010. INTERVENTION Children were randomly allocated to one tertiary appointment followed by up to 11 general practice consultations over one year, supported by shared care, web based software (intervention) or "usual care" (control). Researchers collecting outcome measurements, but not participants, were blinded to group assignment. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Children's body mass index z score (primary outcome), body fat percentage, waist circumference, physical activity, quality of diet, health related quality of life, self esteem, and body dissatisfaction and parents' body mass index (all 15 months post-enrolment). RESULTS 118 (60 intervention, 56 control) children were recruited and 107 (91%) were retained and analysed (56 intervention, 51 control). All retained intervention children attended the tertiary appointment and their general practitioner for at least one (mean 3.5 (SD 2.5, range 1-11)) weight management consultation. At outcome, children in the two trial arms had similar body mass index (adjusted mean difference -0.1 (95% confidence interval -0.7 to 0.5; P=0.7)) and body mass index z score (-0.05 (-0.14 to 0.03); P=0.2). Similarly, no evidence was found of benefit or harm on any secondary outcome. Outcomes varied widely in the combined cohort (mean change in body mass index z score -0.20 (SD 0.25, range -0.97-0.47); 26% of children resolved from obese to overweight and 2% to normal weight. CONCLUSIONS Although feasible, not harmful, and highly rated by both families and general practitioners, the shared care model of primary and tertiary care management did not lead to better body mass index or other outcomes for the intervention group compared with the control group. Improvements in body mass index in both groups highlight the value of untreated controls when determining efficacy. TRIAL REGISTRATION Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry ACTRN12608000055303.